The baby pool was a generous three feet deep at one end, and the two of us sat up to our necks in water just cool enough to be a relief from the brutal North Carolina heat. Her youngest child was Timmy's age and had passed his swim test, so she didn't need to be here with Joey and me -- she wanted to. Sometimes she'd playfully grab Joey's ankle has he swam away squealing and laughing, like she was some kind of swamp monster. We had just met that day, and we were talking about all kinds of things -- school, Okinawa (we'd both been stationed there), England (she was from there), having kids when young (her), having kids when not so young, jobs we've had, of course COVID, and our families. That morning I had posted in a local Marine officers spouse Facebook group, looking for ideas for how to keep a bored nine-year-old occupied. We had just moved to this new neighborhood and were going through a rough time with Timmy, and a rough time in general with all the upheaval that 2020 had to offer. She commented on the post saying she had a son that age and that they were always looking for things to do. We messaged back and forth a few times and arranged to meet at the base pool that afternoon.
Before I knew it, two-and-a-half hours had gone by, and I'd sailed painlessly through the doldrums of a summer afternoon. Our kids had played together for hours, had had frozen treats from the concession stand, and were now exhausted, but not in a cranky, melting-down kind of way. I felt like this new person and I had shared a burden, and in doing so, had lightened it for us both. It had been so effortless. Just two people in a pool, sharing life for a little while.
That evening sitting on the couch I opened up the Facebook profile of my new friend. Then I sat there nonplussed, staring at the screen like "Uhhhhhhh..." Her cover photo was a meme I think most of us have seen a bunch of times. It was a cartoon about Bob voting Republican, Sally voting Democrat, but then the words saying that they are still friends because they're adults were crossed out. The gist of it was that if you are a Trump voter, you're a terrible person, we have nothing in common, and can never be friends. I showed it to Tim, having already filled him in on my day. He shook his head, sighed, and said, "Nothing good is going to come out of this. Someone like this will not be forgiving." What he was really getting at was, "I just don't want you to get hurt." I clicked away without friending her. But then we saw each other a few more times that summer at the pool, and another time in the fall, when I swung by her house to pick up a golden pothos that she had propagated. It is one of my favorite plants, and I remember her every time I see it. I am not looking for a deep friendship, but I like having a friendly face out there. As long as our paths continue to cross, I'm always going to want to wave and smile at the very least; and if time allows, and ask her how things are going.
I, too, am a person who sees things in black and white. I've given up social media for Lent, but my Facebook newsfeed is an echo chamber, in which I like and agree with those who are pro everything I'm pro, and anti everything I'm anti. I admit to unfollowing those who are outspoken in opinions I don't agree with. Close family members get a pass on being wrong, as well as a few dear friends. If they don't fall under either of those categories, I can know usually by a quick glance at their profile whether they're "my people" or not. Sometimes an article will pop up with a title like, "OK, Lazy Mom at the Playground, I'll Watch My Child AND Yours," and I usually resist clicking on it or the comments because I know I'll only see people destroying one another. Everything is us or them, and I have no use for them. I admitted as much to Tim a few months ago, saying that I know I'm part of the problem, but I can't help it. Tim had to give up Facebook for while as well, because he was tired of going down rabbit holes and being outraged all the time.
Recently, although it's been going on for quite some time, I've become aware of something very sinister afoot, a concerted effort to divide everyone on any and every possible line. I watched and then made my kids watch the Netflix documentary The Social Dilemma. I think this is something everyone ought to see because it's affecting everyone regardless of whether they're even on social media themselves. Then I read a book called Them: Why We Hate Each Other - and How to Heal by Ben Sasse, which goes into the history of how for the last couple decades, community has already been breaking down, with people less likely to be rooted to one place, to join clubs, and to get to know the people around them. The resulting loneliness drives them online where they seek connection they lack in real life. They are turning to "anti-tribalism" and political hatred to fill the void of not belonging to any real "tribe." We have outside enemies that are exploiting this situation and they're going to get us Americans to do their dirty work of destroying our own democracy. I think we've all seen some ugly fruits of those efforts in the last couple elections, and it's only the beginning.
An already bad situation became worse when COVID came on the scene. With masks covering half our faces, we're even less likely to see one another as individuals. When everything got canceled and we were discouraged from leaving our houses, we got deprived of whatever real-life connections to other people that we had to begin with. Frightened and suspicious, hunkered down in our own corners, we rage at everyone else.
But it wasn't always like this! I remember the good old days when I set up my own Facebook account after many months of looking over Tim's shoulder as he scrolled through his. I was a little scared to take the plunge, but then I picked the most recent and best post-haircut photo I had for my profile, and went for it. I would take seriously the prompt, "What's on your mind, Rachael?" and I had an audience of family and and a smattering of friends I was sure were hanging on my every word when I shared, "Rachael is so excited, she got both girls to nap at the same time and is going to get all kinds of things done!" For years I would share an album of pictures from every milestone of our life, and every trip we took, and eagerly scroll through those of my friends. My circle grew with every move and new person I met. I relished the feeling of always being connected, no matter where we were. As a shy introvert, I could smooth away any awkwardness by taking the time carefully craft my words, and only share the photos that showed me and my family in the most flattering light.
But I recall that it wasn't long after that I began to see a dark side to all this. I would share something that meant something to me, and when it wouldn't get more than a couple likes, I would think, does anyone care? Comparison reared its ugly head too, because I had some really popular friends whose posts would get a ton of likes. I remember the first time I realized that not everyone was thrilled by what I had to say. The year was 2010, and I took to Facebook hoping to commiserate with other moms of toddlers, saying something like, "This kid won't stop asking me questions!" A person I was well acquainted with in real life commented, "I would give anything to be having conversations like that with my son." Her autistic son. I realized how thoughtless and ungrateful my words had been. It was a good lesson for me -- I would never again complain on social media about a developmentally typical child doing developmentally typical things. And really, if I'm griping about anything besides the weather or the flu, I'm going to offend someone. There is always someone who would love to trade places with me on my worst day, and I would do well to remember that.
The pictures are still great, and so is being connected with friends and family from afar, but over the years it has just gotten bogged down with so much crap.
I've become increasingly guarded and filtered as the years go by, almost to the point where I mainly lurk, like the stuff I agree with, and occasionally post the pictures that I think would mean a lot to some others to see. I'm rarely moved to post anymore, or even comment. If I'm being honest with myself, it's maybe in part due to insecurity. It's also that somewhere along the way I realized it's not healthy to always be bouncing things off such a large number of people, and then waiting for their agreement, or admiration, or affirmation, whatever it is I'm looking to get. Instead, sometimes I'll take a photo or I'll find something that strikes me funny or thought-provoking, even the occasional gripe, and I'll share it with the one person, or a handful of people, who will get it. Like Tim, or my mom or siblings, or an old friend from high school. Even if they didn't appreciate it, I would still know that they love me. I can see that the more I've pulled back from social media, the better off I've been. Still, as I told Tim the day I decided to give up social media for Lent, I didn't/don't know if I could give it up forever. That would mean missing out on all the cute pregnancy announcements, family pictures of people I knew way back when our kids crawled around together, and just important life updates. Not to mention some good sales! "Mostly the pictures, though," I lamented. "I'll never see anyone's pictures again, and they mean so much to me. Even the people I knew in real life for two years back in 2005." He said, "If you had never seen these people's pictures, are you telling me you couldn't have a happy life?" I had to admit that if I had never seen them, I wouldn't know what I was missing, so yeah, I guess I could have a happy life without them.
On the second day of Lent I got an email notification that a friend of mine wanted to tag herself in some of my photos, and man, I was dying to click over and see what photos those were. I forwarded the email to Tim, saying, "The machine knows me well. It knows I don't like to ignore a friend and I love photos." When I said "the machine," I was referring again to The Social Dilemma. Photo-tagging in particular was discussed, with one of the creators of the technology saying, "Do you ever wonder why the photo isn't in the email?"
I have a feeling that in a few weeks I'm going to be back on Facebook and Instagram, scrolling past a lot of crap and looking at everyone's beautiful photos in their Easter attire. Maybe I'll give myself some new limits. For one thing, I refuse to consume any of the articles. My news is going to have to come from other places (still trying to work out what places those should be. I'm woefully uninformed but don't know what sources to trust), and I'm not going to spend any of my time on there being angry at people, or thinking about how they're wrong or stupid. Another limit would be the amount of time I spend, and that will probably be the hardest to enforce. I need never put the apps back on my phone ever again, that's for sure. Who knows how many minutes of my real life I've traded away in exchange for a few photos, a few good deals, and a lot of negativity.
"When we look around our neighborhoods, we should have eyes to see that we share common interests and goals that are more important than just about any questions of federal policy -- chief among those goals, raising our children to become kind, thoughtful, gritty, respectful adults who use their skills and talents to serve others. I don't want to worry that politics is going to prevent my neighbor from keeping an eye on my kids when they're all playing in the front yard." These words from Senator Ben Sasse's conclusion of Them sum it up best for me. This is what's challenging me to get out of my little bubble, get out from behind a screen, and talk with actual people. So scary! Unfiltered Rachael sometimes says the wrong thing. The (metaphorical) mask could slip, and they'll see the real me, not the edited me with the carefully chosen words. I might even, although I shudder to think it, disagree with someone in person. Following the example of volunteerism set by my husband and our parents, I'm volunteering a few hours a month at our parish and school, and will be encouraging our kids to find their own opportunities to serve. We chose to buy in this neighborhood because we saw families and kids outside interacting and dared to hope that we could become part of a real, physical community. And, oh boy, I hesitate to even type out these words, but I am toying with the idea of attending an HOA meeting. And then I'll have the right to complain about whatever I think could be improved in this neighborhood.
It's an interesting experiment, two suburban moms in the wild who met each other and had a face to face conversation before they'd had the chance to learn from social media that they had every reason to hate each other. I understand Tim's instinct to protect me. He knows me well, and he's seen how much rejection, real or perceived, wounds me. But if and when the rejection happens, I refuse to take it personally. She won't be rejecting me as a person -- just as a symbol for everything she's against. It's a risk I'm willing to take. I will not hide my beliefs if they come up in conversation, but neither will I issue her this disclaimer: "Before we meet at the pool again, you might want to know I'm a registered Republican."